After High Praise In 2026, Anthony Potestio Isn't Satisfied

When Baseball America posted a late September article highlighting the 10 standout pro debuts from the 2026 MLB Draft Class, it was unsurprising to see many of the top prospects on the list. 1st and 2nd round picks like Carson Tinney, Drew Burress, and 3rd overall pick Vahn Lackey were all present. What was surprising was who came in 2nd: Yankees 11th round pick Anthony Potestio. In fact, of the 10 players on the list, only Potestio and Yankees 19th round pick, Tyce Armstrong, were not selected in the top two rounds. Us at Yankees Farm had the pleasure of speaking to Potestio about his hot start, as well as many other topics, in a recent discussion.
Anthony Potestio comes from a baseball family, with both his dad and uncle being drafted and playing in the minor leagues. “Something I’m experiencing now, he already went through. Always having that guidance was huge for me” said Potestio. From Northern California, Potestio earned only 1 D1 offer: UC San Diego. He accepted the offer and didn’t look back. Potestio played a major role all 3 seasons at UCSD, finishing off his career as the leadoff hitter for the Tritons.
While the Big West may not be the SEC, that didn’t stop Potestio from having to face legitimate MLB talent. Tyler Bremner and Jackson Flora, the 1st pitchers taken in the 2025 and 2026 draft, respectively, both came out of the Big West conference. “It’s not the SEC but we still have a lot of good talent, a lot of good players. You can’t just show up and expect success everyday you show up at the ballpark.” With a .312/.430/.451 slash line in 129 collegiate games, Potestio worked hard and found success. In his junior season in 2026, Potestio finished 2nd on the team in OPS.
The strong junior campaign positioned him to be selected on day 2 of the MLB draft, though he wasn’t sure where. There was plenty of buzz around him, having talked to area scouts going back to the fall. Yet it would come to pass that on draft day, he would get the call from the Yankees while in his backyard. “It was surreal… I knew it was the Yankees but you don’t even think about that when you see your name up there.” The Yankees selected Potestio in the 11th round with the 338th pick in the draft. Drafted on a Sunday, Potestio made his way to the team’s facility on Tuesday, signed his contract Wednesday, and began his professional baseball journey.
Potestio made his debut for the Tampa Tarpons on August 5th. In his 3rd at bat, Potestio took a sinker on the outer half of the plate over the center field wall for his first professional home run. He would finish the season with 5 home runs in 19 games. It was a compelling power outburst by a hitter who only hit 4 home runs in 49 collegiate games this year and 11 in his entire college career. While his exit velocities weren’t anything special, Potestio credits the Yankees with diagnosing a quick way he could add some power to his game. “They showed me where I hit the ball, they have the technology to see that I hit it a little deeper. When I got there, we practiced hitting the ball out in front… Loading a little earlier, starting a little earlier, and that kind of helped me gain some power… Not changing my swing, not changing my approach, just learning to hit the ball out in front more.”
Indeed, Potestio’s strongest skills are his swing decisions and ability to make contact. In his small sample, Potestio had a 100th percentile chase rate (10.6%) and 89th percentile whiff rate (19.5%). Aggression earlier in counts knowing that he has the skills to fight in two strike counts and take pitches the other way allowed his offensive performance to flourish. “Early in the count lets try to get after one.” In his 19 game sample, Potestio slashed .333/.513/.684 with 5 HR, 17.5 K%, 23.8 BB% for a 203 wRC+.
The recognition was not lost on Potestio, who admitted that it did feel good to have his name on the map, but wasn't getting complacent. “I try not to pay too much attention, I see it and it’s awesome, but I know there is still a lot of work to do.” While the 19-game sample certainly created a lot of excitement for what the infielder will do next, he is by no means a finished product, saying "I have way more to prove than just a few games in Low-A."
When asked where he will look to improve, the answer was easy: Power. “Main focus for me is getting stronger” Potestio said, referencing his exit velocities multiple times. While his average exit velocity of 87.7mph ranked well, 90th percentile EV and Max EV are much more indicative of game power. His 90th percentile EV was 102.6mph, in the 53rd percentile. His max EV was 105, in the 22nd percentile. He plans to hit the weight room plenty this summer, as well as using the bat speed program given to him by the Yankees player development team.
The goal right now for Potestio is to have a strong spring training and position himself to start the season at High-A Hudson Valley. Still, there is a lot to learn, and Potestio seems excited and prepared to improve. Potestio will obviously see some regression over a larger sample, but he has established himself as a prospect to watch in the Yankees system. Myself, as well as the rest of the team at Yankees Farm, can’t wait to see what he has in store for his first full season.




Comments