The Rule 5 Gamble: How a Looming Lockout Complicates the Yankees’ 40-Man Decisions

It's that time of the baseball offseason, when the hot stove starts to warm up, front offices across the league are focused on the annual roster shuffling crunch: deciding which prospects to add to the 40-man roster to protect them from the Rule 5 Draft, and which ones to leave exposed to the rest of the league. Tomorrow 6 PM is the deadline for teams to make a decision on which players to add to the 40 man roster.
Right now, the Yankees sit at 33 rostered players, giving Brian Cashman and company 7 open spots to protect their top prospects or sign free agents before the deadline, and I'm expecting maybe 4-5 prospects to be added to that list.
This is usually a pretty straight decision to make, but this time around there's another element to consider. MLB's current Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA) is expiring, and most experts belive baseball is headed for a dreaded lockout.
Here lies the current dilemma of adding young prospects to the 40 man roster right now:
The moment a prospect is added to the 40 man roster, they become unionized MLBPA members. That meanas if a work stoppage occurs, their development instantly halts. They are locked out. They cannot communicate with team coaches, use organization training facilities like in Tampa or New York, work with team medical staff, or participate in minor league spring training and regular season games until a new CBA is ratified.
That said, Minor League Baseball (MiLB) operates under its own separate collective bargaining agreement. If MLB does begin a lockout, the minor league season proceeds uninterrupted, and players strictly on minor league contracts will continue playing, training at team facilities, receiving coaching, and getting that needed development time.
This creates a high stakes gamble for Brian Cashman. Protect a raw development arm like Carlos Lagrange or Allen Facundo, and you risk stunting their growth, and stranding them in developmental purgatory for months if labor talks stall. Leave them off to ensure they keep developing, and you risk losing them for nothing in the Rule 5 Draft. For high ranked prospects like Lagrange and Arias, protecting them remains a necessity, but the threat of lost development time makes every single roster selection significantly heavier this winter.
Here is the full breakdown of who the Yankees should be adding to the 40-man roser and who stays on the fence:
The Must Protect Prospects
1. Carlos Lagrange, SP (SWB RailRiders)
This one is a no brainer. Lagrange is very close to the Big and leaving him exposed to the Rule 5 draft would be negligence. Lagrange has seen his stock jump exponentially over the last two seasons, as his command has show improvement and his development has taken huge steps forward. The towering right stands 6'7 with a big triple digits fastball with a nasty slider, who put up a nearly 13 Ks per 9 this season. A weapon that the Yankees desperately need in the back of their bullpen.
2. Roderick Arias, SS/3B (Somerset Patriots)
The Yankees handed Arias $4 Million as the crown jewel of their international signing class for a reason. While his early pro seasons hit some bumps with injuries and ballooning strikeout rates, he finally showed genuine signs of the blue chip prospect the Yankees signed, down the stretch this past season. The raw tools, elite twitch athleticism, plus plus arm strength, and dynamic bat speed remained visible as his overall production stabilized.
On the bubble teams routinely use Rule 5 picks on former top tier international bonus babies to stash on the bench as utility pieces, as we saw with Marco Luciano this season. Arias seems to have found the next level and has settled in at 3B nicely, a position the organization hasn't been able to produce from since Miguel Andujar.
3. Allen Facundo, LHP (Hudson Valley Renegades)
Right alongside Lagrange and Selvidge as an absolute protection lock is Allen Facundo. The Venezuelan southpaw has established himself as one of the most intriguing left handed throwing weapons in the system.
Armed with a high spin fastball/slider mix capable of hitting 99 MPH that destroys left handed hitters and an ascending starter profile, Facundo carries high leverage MLB upside. Left handed pitching with legitimate swing and miss stuff is the highest commodity in baseball; he will not make it past the first few picks of the draft if left exposed. He could easily be moved to a bullpen role and could move quickly. Protect him.
Upper Level Power & High Upside Bats
4. Jace Avina, OF (Somerset Patriots)
Acquired from the Milwaukee Brewers alongside Brian Sánchez in the Jake Bauers trade, Avina put together a dominant, career defining season at Double A Somerset. He launched 21 home runs, stole 16 bases, and posted a strong .254/.350/.467 line with a 120 wRC+. Pairing double digit home run pop with double digit walk rates and a low groundball rate, he drives the ball into the air consistently. Avina provides high upside outfield depth with real offensive pop the exact profile of a 4th outfielder a retooling team would gladly snatch up.
5. Garrett Martin, OF (SWB RailRiders)
Martin forced his way directly into this conversation after a monstrous breakout campaign. Pounding upper level pitching in Triple A, Martin put up explosive power numbers backed by elite Statcast metrics highlighted by a 96th percentile ISO of .300 and an EV90 touching 108.6 mph. In todays game, raw power that translates against upper level pitching is an incredibly rare commodity. A team searching for a right handed power bat off the bench would jump at the chance to draft Martin if left unprotected.
6. Brock Selvidge, LHP (Somerset Patriots)
Selvidge is another absolute must protect arm. The lefty has developed into one of the higher floor starting prospects in the upper minors. He showed great flashes in the first Spring Breakout Game and was projecting for good development before an injury sidelined him.
With a polished four pitch mix led by a sweeping slider and heavy sinker, Selvidge eats innings and limits hard contact. Because he has already been battle tested at the Double A level, he is plug and play ready for a non competitive team looking for a rotation arm or long relief option right now.
7. Coby Morales, 1B/3B/OF (Somerset Patriots)
Morales put together a historic breakout campaign in Double A Somerset, earning Eastern League All Star honors after slashing .282/.372/.479 with an .851 OPS and a 129 wRC+ across 130 games. The left handed slugger became just the second player in Somerset franchise history to record a 20/20 season, launching 21 home runs and swiping 21 bags while setting single season team records in games played (130), hits (132), and runs scored (86).
Protecting Morales is a smart move because he pairs genuine power and plate discipline (69 walks in 541 plate appearances) with corner versatility across first base, third base, and right field. A left handed bat coming off a 20/20 season in the upper minors who can play multiple spots and get on base at a .372 clip is an easy target for rebuilding teams looking to stash a ready made bench piece for a full season.
The Elephant in the Room: The Looming Lockout & Roster Catch 22
There is a glaring conflict hanging over this entire process that every front office and every fan needs to monitor. The current Major League Baseball Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA) is set to expire on December 1, 2026, and signs across the industry point toward an impending work stoppage.
Here lies the dangerous double edged sword of adding young prospects to the 40 man roster right now:
The Minor League Exemption: Minor League Baseball (MiLB) operates under its own separate collective bargaining agreement. If MLB enters a lockout, the minor league season will proceed uninterrupted, and players strictly on minor league contracts will continue playing, training at team facilities, receiving coaching, and getting game reps.
The 40 Man Freeze: The moment a prospect is added to the 40 man roster, they become unionized MLBPA members. If a work stoppage occurs, their development instantly halts. They are locked out. They cannot communicate with team coaches, use organization training facilities in Tampa or Scranton, work with Yankees medical staff, or participate in minor league spring training and regular season games until a new CBA is ratified.
This creates a high stakes gamble for Brian Cashman. Protect a raw development arm like Carlos Lagrange or Allen Facundo, and you risk stranding them in developmental purgatory for months if labor talks stall. Leave them off to ensure they keep getting coaching reps in MiLB, and you risk losing them for nothing in the Rule 5 Draft. For core assets like Lagrange and Arias, protecting them remains a necessity, but the threat of lost development time makes every single roster selection significantly heavier this winter.
The On the Fence Priority Tier: High Octane Relief Arms
If Cashman can open up additional roster spots through trades or non tenders before the deadline, the Yankees must do everything in their power to keep these three arms in the system. All three are capable of hitting triple digits, possess the raw power profiles that can be staples in the back of a big league bullpen. With continued next level coaching and organizational development, these pitchers could prove to be massive assets for New York down the line.
Eric Reyzelman, RHP (SWB RailRiders)
Reyzelman continues to showcase an explosive profile tailored for high leverage relief work. Armed with a fastball that rides into the upper 90s and touches 100 MPH alongside a wipeout sweeper, he generates elite strikeout numbers in the upper minors. Relief arms with raw triple digit heat and swing and miss secondaries are frequent Rule 5 targets for teams looking for quick bullpen help. The Yankees should fight to keep his high leverage ceiling in house. When healthy, Reyzelman looks like a legitimate weapon.
Hayden Merda, RHP (SWB RailRiders)
Merda has been a major player to watch. Before an injury cost him development time this season, I was leaning that he could debut at some point later in the season. Standing 6 foot 6, Merda uses his leverage and extension to create uncomfortable angles, heavy velocity, and deception. He'e one of those developmental type arms that could appear out of nowhere into a real back of the bullpen option with next level coaching, making him an asset you hate to lose right before he makes his big league jump.
Luis Velasquez, RHP (Somerset Patriots)
Velasquez is one of the most electric wild cards in the entire organization. Coming off Tommy John surgery, he was pumping 100+ MPH heat before his injury and has the exact raw stuff this bullpen is badly in need of. Power relievers featuring triple digit velocity and sharp breaking pitches do not grow on trees. If he gets back to 100% health, Velasquez projects as a legitimate late inning power arm.
The Low Risk Exposure Tier: A Ball Hopefuls
Luis Serna (SP) & Franyer Herrera (SP)
Serna, and Herrera have shown intriguing flashes down in Tampa and High A Hudson Valley. Serna’s changeup remains a real weapon, while Herrera’s movement profile gives him high relief upside down the road.
Hoping both stick in the system without getting plucked is understandable, but being that they are still down in Single A Ball, the odds of a team selecting them and successfully keeping them on an active 26 man MLB roster for a full season are extremely slim. History shows that carrying Single A pitchers on a big league roster for a full year is almost impossible for front offices to execute. The Yankees can safely risk exposing them to the draft while locking up their closer to ready talent.




Comments